Matt Ellinger, William Harper, Pam Moreno, Stacy Hickey, Adriana Nenciu, Preston Galloway
DNV, Dublin, USA
Abstract
Results from magnetic flux leakage (MFL) in-line inspection (ILI) surveys provide valuable information that help pipeline operators make informed and defensible integrity management decisions. When subsequent ILI survey data are available, meaningful, and data-driven corrosion growth rates can be derived along the length of a pipeline by performing a comprehensive ILI-run-to-run comparison. A comprehensive ILI run-to-run comparison should include the following components:
- ILI bias assessment to compensate for reporting tendencies in one or both of the ILI surveys, thus accounting for tool sensitivities and creating the basis for an apples-to-apples comparison,
- Statistical analysis to identify locations that are most likely to contain active corrosion and derivation of ‘spreadsheet-based’ corrosion growth rates,
- ILI signal-to-signal analysis at target locations (e.g., those that are most likely to contain active corrosion based on the statistical analysis),
- Utilize signal review results to confirm, modify, or negate the statistically derived corrosion growth rates,
- Finalize corrosion growth rates on a per anomaly (i.e., pit-to-pit), per-joint, or per-segment basis, and
- Apply established corrosion growth rates to determine times to criticality for the ILI-reported metal loss anomalies.
ILI vendors typically identify metal loss anomalies that are on (i.e., crossing) the longitudinal seam weld or near (i.e., adjacent to, or in the heat affected zone) of the longitudinal seam weld versus those that are in the pipe body (i.e., away from the longitudinal seam weld). During a comprehensive ILI run-to-run comparison analysis, the authors of this paper observed a trend in which ‘spreadsheet-based’ corrosion growth rates for metal loss anomalies reported on or near the longitudinal seam weld were consistently higher than those reported in the pipe body. Following this observation, the authors performed an in-depth analysis to better understand this trend. The following tasks were completed as a part of the analysis:
- Detailed statistical analysis to identify whether differences between the corrosion growth rates among metal loss anomalies reported on or near the longitudinal seam weld versus those that are in the pipe body are statistically significant.
- Comprehensive signal review comparisons between the subsequent ILI surveys at select and targeted locations that demonstrated the largest differences in corrosion growth rates between metal loss anomalies reported on or near the longitudinal seam weld versus those reported in the pipe body.
- Determine whether ‘true’ corrosion growth rates at metal loss anomalies on or near the longitudinal seam weld are faster than those in the pipe body.
This paper will detail the methodology and results of the authors’ analysis. Key findings and practical applications will be presented. The paper will provide valuable insights into managing pipeline integrity with respect to ILI-reported metal loss anomalies at or near the longitudinal seam weld.



