38 Variability and Mitigative Measures for Estimating Yield Strength in Line Pipe

Abstract

Natural gas pipeline operators in the United States are increasingly implementing materials verification programs (MVP) to validate the properties of pipelines that lack reliable records.  These programs rely on nondestructive testing (NDT) methods, such as Instrumented Indentation Testing (IIT), to estimate the mechanical properties of pipeline steels in situ.  The NDT approach is attractive because it does not require material to be cut from the pipe, as does traditional mechanical/tensile testing.  However, IIT and other NDT methods infer the bulk mechanical properties from a relatively thin surface layer, and extrapolation to through-wall properties can introduce errors due to factors including material inhomogeneity and residual stresses from manufacturing.  This work will consider the variability in the IIT yield strength from seven line pipes tested in multiple locations by two different vendors.   It will be shown that while the measured IIT yield strength is often within ±10% of the tensile test result, some results can exceed this range.  Furthermore, it will be shown that the yield strength estimated by IIT can vary by as much as 20% based on both the axial and circumferential location on the pipe. Sources of this variation, including the effects of sampling depth, will be discussed with consideration of residual stress, decarburization, and alloying variability.  Recommendations will be made for best practices to identify and mitigate measurement uncertainty related to these effects.

Read/Download PaperGradeAvailable after the event