30 In-Depth Review of DOT 192 & 195 Pipeline Incidents and Accidents for 2010-2021

Abstract

For the past two years I have presented at the GPA-Midstream conferences on individual analysis of the natural gas transmission and hazardous liquids pipeline PHMSA incident and accident history.  Over the last decade, natural gas pipeline operators experienced $1.4B in damages from 1,364 events. Each of these events had the potential to collect 622 unique data entries related to the incident.  For the hazardous liquids pipelines, the overall costs nearly double at $2.7B in damages on nearly 4,000 events, with a similar count of unique data points required in accident reporting.  The presentation included analysis, trends, and opportunities for improvement.  The initial exercise was initiated after realizing the PHMSA accident reporting form, RSPA F 7000-1, had undergone a significant revision in 2010 and was now collecting more than twice the data of the previous version form.   The same improvements were relevant for PHMSA F 7100.2 I now plan to conduct a comparison of natural gas and hazardous liquid pipeline data sets along with European pipeline accident history and highlight areas of potential improvement in pipeline safety.

My evaluation and analysis consists of the following:

  • A comparison of the form versions and general observations on the now consistent format and units as well as the incremental data collected.
  • Geographical representation of incident history for 2010-2021, with volume and failed asset representation in point size scale and color notation.
  • Asset specific evaluation data for major categories including: Vessel, Compressor, Valve, and Pipe.
  • Each asset category analysis includes unique design trends related to: commodity carried, cause, year of manufacture, failed component, nominal size, seam type, external pipe coating type, and current function.
  • Each asset category analysis includes unique operational trends related to: natural force contributors, incorrect operation factors, equipment activity, year of install, availability and use of procedures, incident identifiers, corrosion type, current corrosion efforts, current integrity programs, and ILI history.
  • Incident release volumes and cost details for each asset were reviewed for financial impact on operators.
  • Operator Annual report data was utilized to identify any disproportionate conditions related to: seam type, manufacture year, etc.
  • Incident costs were evaluated with comparison to consolidated operator Annual Report data for predictive incident volume and cost per mile evaluations.
  • Key observations and recommendations were summarized for each asset category with supporting industry standards and recommended practices references.

I believe this data set and associated presentation provides a useful industry review for the last decade of pipeline incidents and accidents.  Operator representatives for engineering, operations, construction, and HES organizations can benefit from the industry lessons learned, potential risks, and opportunities for improvement.

Keywords: DOT 192 & 195 - Compliance, Operations & Maintenance, Pipeline Safety, and Safety & Reliability

Read/Download PaperGradeAvailable after the event