64 Measuring Toughness with Instrumented Indentation Methods: Fact or Fiction?

Abstract

There is a strong desire among pipeline operators to quantify material properties with nondestructive in-ditch measurements.  In addition to operators’ obvious motivation to maintain pipeline integrity and to avoid releases, PHMSA’s new Mega Rule for vintage gas lines imposes regulatory pressure to characterize pipe properties.  Performing destructive material testing on cut-outs is an effective but very expensive option.  Consequently, the prospect of nondestructive in-ditch material testing is extremely attractive.

A number of vendors offer in-ditch technology to infer yield and tensile strength.  One such technology entails pressing a small spherical indenter into exposed steel on the OD of a pipe joint.  This technique resembles a conventional hardness test, except that these modern indentation devices are instrumented to measure the force versus deflection response.

While instrumented indentation methods are certainly capable of measuring the strength properties of steel, some vendors have claimed that this technology can also measure material toughness.  The present paper examines this claim in detail.

The author invokes basic metallurgical principles to argue that it is simply impossible for an indentation test to “measure” fracture toughness.  The plastic flow properties of steel are weakly related to fracture properties.  That is, two steels with identical strength properties can have very different toughness properties.  The indentation test cannot distinguish between two such steels.  This paper includes experimental benchmarks that demonstrate the lack of correlation between tensile properties and fracture toughness.

Read/Download PaperGradeAvailable after the event