Integrating Pipe Manufacturer Hard Spot Classification with High and Low Field Magnetization for Improved Hardness Prediction

Wednesday - January 27 | 16:00 · 1.2 Hard Spots

Adrian Belanger1, Jing Wang2, Sean Moran3

1T.D. Williamson, Houston, USA, 2TC Energy, Calgary, Canada, 3Williams, Salt Lake City, USA

Due to recent failures in non A. O. Smith manufactured pipe, PHMSA released an advisory bulletin (ADB-2024-01 and Federal Register: 2024-2672) that pipeline owners and operators should consider expanding their hard spot threat evaluation to all pipe manufactured prior to 1970. Even before the PHMSA bulletin, industry has been responding to the threat by initiating research projects through the Pipeline Research Council International (PRCI). These projects focused on two objectives, the susceptibility of manufactured pipe to hard spots (PR727-234502) and the performance of ILI tools in characterizing hard spots (PR335-233813). T. D. Williamson has been conducting hard spot inline inspection (ILI) surveys using the high and low magnetization fields on its multiple data set tools for over ten years. With more recent inspections of pipeline manufacturers other than A. O. Smith and a growing body of dig feedback, a classification scheme has been developed to distinguish between the A. O. Smith hard spots that have been the known integrity threat since 1950's and the hard spots resulting in the more recent failures from other pipe manufacturers. The analysis process is currently in a continual process of refinement as detailed information from the nondestructive examination (NDE) in validation digs has shed new light on the signals measured by the multiple data set tools with high and low magnetization fields. Sufficient data has been collected to incorporate pipe manufacturer as a predictor in the hardness prediction model. Results indicate that hard spots of the same classification can exhibit distinct signal responses between pipe manufacturers, leading to measurable differences in the predicted hardness. This paper describes how the hard spot classification system for different pipe manufacturers was developed through an extensive excavation feedback program conducted by one pipeline operator, and how the resulting insights have been used to refine and validate the analysis for another operator. The findings demonstrate that ongoing collaboration among pipeline operators, ILI providers, and NDE specialists drives continuous improvements in analytical methods. These improvements are transferable across pipeline systems, enhancing both industry research efforts and the overall integrity management of pipeline assets. Keywords: hard spots, low field magnetization, LFM, NDE, A. O. Smith, inline inspection, ILI, pipe manufacturer

Read/Download PaperGradeAvailable after the event