Robotic MLF Inspection Comparison to Wireline MFL in Out of Service Pipelines

Thursday - January 28 | 15:40 · 5.4 Unpiggable or Difficult-to-Inspect 2

Brady Blake1, Dale Simpson2, Jerry Toth3

1Colonial Pipeline, Alpharetta, USA, 2Intero Integrity Services, Calgary, Canada, 3Intero Integrity Services, Houston, USA

Robotic magnetic flux leakage (MFL) inspection and tethered wireline MFL have emerged as effective solutions for evaluating pipelines that are unsuitable for conventional in-line inspection (ILI). Operational constraints such as the absence of launcher and receiver facilities, low-flow or stagnant conditions, tight-radius bends, and significant geometric restrictions (e.g., dents) often limit the applicability of traditional pigging technologies. In these scenarios, both robotic and tethered MFL systems provide viable alternatives for integrity assessment. This paper presents a comparative evaluation of robotic and tethered wireline MFL technologies based on their application in out-of-service tank lines within the Colonial Pipeline system. By deploying both methods on similar assets, a direct side-by-side comparison is conducted to assess performance, data quality, operational considerations, and deployment efficiency. The findings highlight the respective strengths of each approach and provide guidance on technology selection for challenging pipeline inspection scenarios.

Read/Download PaperGradeAvailable after the event