Small Dents, Big Results: A Year of 192.712(c) Dent ECA

Thursday - January 28 | 11:30 · 6.2 Dent Assessment & Management 1

Rhett Dotson1, Rob Greene1, Brian Jimenez2, Robert Burke2

1D2 Integrity, Houston, USA, 2Energy Transfer, Houston, USA

Under 49 CFR 192.712(c), operators can use an engineering critical assessment (ECA) to evaluate dents rather than relying only on prescriptive remediation criteria. This paper reviews the first full year that a large natural gas pipeline operator used an approved 192.712(c) dent ECA process, covering 305 individual dent assessments. Results are grouped by dent classification and by interacting features, including metal loss, welds, and geohazards. For each group, the paper reports how often dents passed the ECA. For dents that did not pass, it identifies and discusses the reasons for failure and possible identifying characteristics to improve screening to reveal dents that may not be applicable for the 192.712(c) process. The paper also describes the challenges the operator, the engineering consultant, and the ILI vendors faced while putting the process into routine use. It presents lessons learned for improving project response time and data completeness. Operators planning to adopt the 192.712(c) framework can use these lessons to set realistic expectations and help to streamline their dent ECA programs.

Read/Download PaperGradeAvailable after the event